Indiana Economic Digest | Indiana
Advanced Search

• Most Recent

home : most recent : most recent November 14, 2018

10/24/2018 8:58:00 AM
EDITORIAL: Scooters, the environment and city rules


City officials continue to tout the scooter invasion as an edgy, smart strategy to provide environmentally friendly transportation, especially for that “last mile” before work or school. But is that true?

A good deal of research can be found online and comes to differing conclusions. One metric used often involves how much of a carbon savings there is when scooters are used instead of cars. These studies say scooters are magnificent sustainability tools for last-mile travel in cities.

Other studies question whether use of electric scooters, especially in coal-dependent states such as Indiana, really do cut down on carbon emissions.

One key point: Bloomington isn’t a big city with trains and buses that get people to within a mile of their destination, then require a last-mile solution.

Another key point: Anecdotal evidence — the simple eye test — would suggest that a majority of scooter riders are college-age students who would most likely be riding bicycles, walking or taking buses rather than driving cars into the city. Walking is more friendly to the environment and personal health than the scooters.

City regulations should come ASAP to mitigate the annoyances and dangers to pedestrians and the riders themselves in the short term. In the long term, the issue of whether scooters in major university towns actually mitigate carbon emissions or add to them would be a good job for a doctoral student in the School of Public and Environmental Affairs.

Being mesmerized by the coolfactor of this innovation should not be an option.

Related Stories:
• Bird scooters: Lafayette gives reprieve on cease and desist order
• EDITORIAL: No scooters on Indiana highways
• Scooter rules sought by Bloomington Bicycle and Pedestrian Safety Commission
• Bird scooters: Lafayette gives reprieve on cease and desist order
• Suddenly they are everywhere in Bloomington: Scooter, bike share growth still an open question
• After impounding Bird scooters, Purdue gets its own fleet, this time for research
• Purdue: $50 tickets coming for bad scooter riders
• Bloomington officials: Treat scooters like bicycles
• Lime launches scooters: South Bend pilot project to last 45 days

Copyright #YYYY#, HeraldTimesOnline, Bloomington, IN

Editor, John C. DePrez Jr.; Executive Editor, Carol Rogers; Publishers: IBRC and IAR

Software © 1998-2018 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved